By William H. Dray

ISBN-10: 0198238819

ISBN-13: 9780198238812

This e-book explains and defends a significant rules within the idea of heritage recommend by way of R. G. Collingwood, maybe the major thinker of heritage within the twentieth century. Professor Dray analyses seriously the belief of re-enactment, explores the boundaries of its applicability, and determines its dating to different key Collingwoodian principles, equivalent to the function of mind's eye in historic pondering, and the indispensability of some extent of view.

Show description

Read Online or Download History As Re-enactment: R. G. Collingwood's Idea of History (Clarendon Paperbacks) PDF

Similar epistemology books

Barry Stroud's The Significance of Philosophical Scepticism PDF

This ebook increases questions on the character of philosophy via studying the resource and value of 1 vital philosophical challenge: how do we understand something in regards to the international round us? Stroud discusses and criticizes the perspectives of such philosophers as Descartes, Kant, J. L. Austin, G. E. Moore, R.

Representation and Productive Ambiguity in Mathematics and by Emily R. Grosholz PDF

Emily Grosholz bargains an unique research of demonstration in arithmetic and technology, interpreting the way it works and why it truly is persuasive. targeting geometrical demonstration, she exhibits the jobs that illustration and ambiguity play in mathematical discovery. She offers a variety of case reports in mechanics, topology, algebra, common sense, and chemistry, from historic Greece to the current day, yet focusing quite at the 17th and 20th centuries.

P.F. Strawson's Scepticism and Naturalism: Some Varieties PDF

First released in 1987. Routledge is an imprint of Taylor & Francis, an informa corporation.

Kelly Becker, Tim Black's The sensitivity principle in epistemology PDF

The sensitivity precept is a compelling proposal in epistemology and is usually characterised as an important situation for wisdom. This number of 13 new essays constitutes a state of the art dialogue of this significant precept. a number of the essays construct on and increase sensitivity-based bills of data and provide novel defences of these money owed.

Additional resources for History As Re-enactment: R. G. Collingwood's Idea of History (Clarendon Paperbacks)

Sample text

37 Here the interpretation of Collingwood's view of re-enactment makes contact with contemporary analyses of action explanation as the aScription of implicit practical arguments (to be discussed further in Ch. 3, § 3). Re-enactment and Understanding Re-enactment and Understanding to test it, to see whether it can really be thought. 38 The insistence that re-enactment must be critical thus points to a quasi-normative dimension in historical understanding. 39 To understand an action in a properly historical way is in some degree to see it as having been appropriate to the circumstances as the agent saw them.

There is more than a hint of this in the approval he expresses of Croce's 'mature' doctrine that the distinctive feature of historical, by contrast with scientific, thought, is concern with the individual. e. re-enactively, if not outwardly, makes perfectly good sense. 46 But if, as was argued above, the idea of understanding an action re-enactively implies, among other things, discovering a universal significance in its expressed idea, any claim that it can be understood 'in itself is surely ruled out.

In Chapter 1, I drew attention to two different 60 § 7. History as Knowledge of the Individual In the chapter to follow, I shall endeavour to explicate Collingwood's idea of historical understanding further by contrasting his view of it as re-enactment in a little more detail with his conception of explanation in the natural sciences. I shall also contrast the interpretation of re-enactment itself which I have outlined here with two somewhat different interpretations which have enjoyed some support.

Download PDF sample

History As Re-enactment: R. G. Collingwood's Idea of History (Clarendon Paperbacks) by William H. Dray

by William

Rated 4.01 of 5 – based on 5 votes